How selling works
Three steps. No haggling.Get a quote
Head to sell.bigcritcrew.com and start a submission — search your cards in one at a time or upload a whole list (Manabox, TCGplayer, Deckbox and more), and the quote engine prices every card on the spot. Works the same for a single binder or a full estate; large and graded lots welcome.
Just exploring? Ask the Pricing Agent anything, or spot-check a single card on the price checker — then bring it to a submission when you're ready.
We verify
Checked against live market data and reviewed by a real buyer. No algorithmic lowballs — if something looks off, a human fixes it before you're quoted.
Get paid
Same-day payment for locals; prompt settlement on mail-ins. Choose your method:
Want the full walkthrough — CSV imports, drafts, quote review, shipping? Read the deep dive at sell.bigcritcrew.com/how-it-works.