BigCritCrew Card Submissions
From upload to payout

How it works.

The whole submission flow, end to end. Transparent at every step — you see the same data we use to make our offer.

01
Upload

Start with a list.

Drop a CSV from Manabox, Moxfield (CSV or .txt deck list), Deckbox, Dragon Shield, Collectr, or the TCGPlayer Seller Portal. The format is auto-detected from the header row — no field mapping required.

Don't have a CSV? Add cards manually with full-text autocomplete and per-card condition / foil / language pickers. Mixed games in one submission are fine — Magic, Pokémon, and One Piece all live in the same draft.

  • Drafts auto-save to your browser for a year
  • Up to ~5,000 cards per submission
  • Image preview + correct-printing matching as you go
02
Quote & review

See the price, then real eyes.

Every card runs through our live buy-rate engine the moment you add it: current TCGPlayer market price, our condition multipliers (NM through DMG), foil/non-foil split, and any active floor pricing for bulk Magic. The auto-quote is the starting point — not a lowball trick.

When you submit, the draft moves to our buyer queue. We hand-check alt-arts, foils, condition edge cases, and anything ambiguous — the same review a card gets across the counter at the shop. If the final offer differs from the auto-quote, we send notes line-by-line so you know exactly why. Most submissions land within ~24 hours.

Lightning Bolt · M11 · NM $1.62
Charizard ex · 199/197 · NM $11.34
Monkey D. Luffy · OP01-001 · LP $3.78
3 items $16.74
03
Ship & get paid

Pick your payout.

Accept the offer and we send a prepaid shipping label. Drop the cards at any carrier counter — once they arrive and verify clean, payment goes out the same business day.

Same-day

Payment goes out the same business day your cards verify clean.

Local? Cash in hand

Southeastern Michigan drop-offs get paid on the spot.

Our commitments

What we won't do.

The buylist industry has earned its reputation. Here's how we're trying to be different.

No bait-and-switch quotes

The number you see at submission is the number we hand-review against — not a placeholder that gets cut once we have your cards.

No selling your data

Email + cards + payout method. That's all we collect. No analytics resold, no email-list trading, no third-party trackers.

No "auto-grade-down"

Cards aren't downgraded on a whim. If we adjust condition, you get a note explaining what we saw — with photo evidence on request.

No silence

Every submission has a contact thread inside the portal. Ask questions, request clarification, get a real reply.

Ready when you are.

Start a draft — no commitment until you submit.

Back to Home